
Am I doing enough home education? A primary teacher's perspective
Why comparing your home education day with a school timetable can create unnecessary worry, and what really matters when looking at your child's learning.
It's the end of the day. There was some reading, a bit of maths that went better than yesterday, and a walk that turned into a long conversation about something you didn't see coming. Then, once they're in bed, the question arrives: was that enough?
I'm a primary teacher, in my seventeenth year, and I'm not a home educator. So I'm writing this from the other side of the fence, from inside a classroom. What I can offer is a look at what actually fills a school day, because I think a lot of the worry about "enough" comes from measuring home against school. Once you see what a school day is made of, that comparison looks very different.
What actually fills a school day?
A lot of a school day exists because there are thirty children in one room.
Think about what that takes. Registration. Lining up. Moving from one room to another. Coats on, and then coats off again because it has stopped raining. Waiting while the last few finish, so the whole class can move on together. Explaining the same thing three different ways, because thirty children heard it thirty different ways.
And those are just the tip of the iceberg! I have lost twenty minutes or more from the lesson straight after lunch because there has been an argument over football, for the fifth time that week. Or a group of best friends have fallen out, and now they're all in tears and none of them can see their part in what caused it. With one adult in the room, these things eat into teaching time very often. But if they are not resolved, learning suffers, at least for the children involved and often for the whole class, because what those children do next affects everyone around them.
None of this is anybody's fault. I have spent a good part of seventeen years saying "I'll wait until everyone is ready", and I'm still not convinced everyone has ever been ready at the same time. It's simply what teaching a large group costs. Schools also have a long list of things they are required to fit in, and every one of them comes out of the same day.
At home, most of that falls away. Home has its own juggling, of course: siblings, interruptions, a bad night, additional needs that shape every day. But you are working around your own family, not twenty-nine other children, and that gives you room a classroom rarely has. When something has clicked, you can stop. When it hasn't, you can stay with it for as long as it takes, without anyone else waiting. So when you compare a morning at your kitchen table with a full school day, you aren't comparing like with like.
What is left when you take that out?
Much less than most parents fear, and much more manageable.
Some skills build on each other, and that is worth knowing whichever way you home educate. Children come to reading and number in different ways and at different times, and sounding out words or counting on fingers is a normal part of getting there. What's worth noticing is when a step stays hard work for a long time. A child who is still working hard to sound out most words may not have much left over for following the story. A child who needs their fingers for every fact may find bigger maths heavy going. When something feels stuck, it is often worth looking at the step underneath it. That is the part that deserves some careful thought, and how and when you get there is entirely up to you.
A lot of the rest doesn't have to come in any particular order. Nobody needs the Romans before the Tudors, or plants before magnets. If your child is fascinated by volcanoes this month, that's where the science, the geography and some of the writing can come from.
And some of what can feel like time off is learning. Being read to from books harder than they could manage on their own. Proper conversations, including the awkward questions. Time outside. Making things. For a primary age child, that is a large part of an education.
Starting from where they are
Children learn best when the new thing builds on something they already know, at a pace that suits them. That sounds obvious, but a classroom can only ever get close to it, because one pace has to work for thirty.
That's why I think in stages rather than school years. A stage is about what a child can already do and what makes sense next. A year group is about how old they are. A child can be well ahead in one area and taking their time in another, and that is completely ordinary. Comparing your child with what is "expected" for their age can knock your confidence without telling you anything you can use. Being "behind" on a chart doesn't tell you what to do on Tuesday morning. Knowing what your child can do now, and what comes next for them, does.
The law in England, in section 7 of the Education Act 1996, says parents must make sure their child receives an efficient, full-time education suitable to their age, ability and aptitude, and to any special educational needs they may have. The government's guidance for parents explains what that means in practice. Ability, aptitude and special educational needs are all in that sentence for a reason. The route, the pace and where your child ends up are for your family to decide.
Enjoying it is part of how it works
Children remember what they were interested in. When they are enjoying something, they stay with it longer, ask more questions and come back to it on their own. So following your child's interest is not cutting corners. A morning spent building a den, measuring it, and writing instructions so a younger cousin can build one too has more maths and writing in it than it looks. Give them a few things the den has to do, then ask them to look back at their choices and say how they'd improve it, and they have planned, built, tested and rethought something real, in a few hours of fun.
What to look for instead of counting hours
Hours are a poor measure at home. These questions tell you more:
-
What have they been interested in lately, and where has it taken them?
-
Can they explain something they've been learning, in their own words?
-
What can they do now that they couldn't do a few months ago?
-
Are they enjoying it, and more confident about having a go?
-
Is anything hard work every time, where they might need some extra support?
-
Is the challenge about right for them? Enough that it isn't boring, but not so much that it puts them off.
There is no pass mark. If an answer surprises you, it shows you where to look next, and that is useful on its own.
In my experience, the focused teaching in a school day often adds up to an hour and a half, maybe two hours. The rest is everything else that comes with thirty children. So a day at home that looks light on lessons can still have plenty of learning in it. A lot of it won't look like a lesson at all, and a good part of it will go on them growing as individuals, which is something home is especially well placed for.
About the author
Mark Rajakrishnen is a primary teacher in his seventeenth year. He has mentored and coached trainee and early career teachers and was a Quality of Education Lead. He lives in West Yorkshire.
























